I’ve been reading Yalom and Leszcz’s Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy and came across the concept of the “corrective emotional experience” as they described the therapeutic process in group psychotherapy. I initially felt hopeful and encouraged. But the more I sat with the concept, the more disturbed I felt.
Where the Idea Comes From
The term was coined by Franz Alexander in 1946. He wrote that patients, “while affectively interacting with their therapist in a distorted fashion because of transference…become aware their reactions are not suited to the situation between patient and therapist and are equally unsuited to the patient’s current relationships in his daily life.” Change, then, occurs “through a disconfirmation of the client’s pathogenic beliefs.”
This previously always felt inspiring to me. I could strive to be the “good” relationship that my clients internalize, replacing many of the harmful people and influences they’ve absorbed over a lifetime.
But I now realize that a therapeutic stance in which the therapist is the “good” other comes at a cost.
The Hidden Cost of Being the “Good” Other
Namely, in situations where I inevitably felt non-”unconditional positive regard” affects with my clients (which all real relationships will stir at some point) or I found myself behaving like the very people in their story that wounded them, I would become fearful, ashamed, and often apologize and try to get back to “being good again” thus abandoning myself and the drama that was being enacted.
Of course, I still ultimately hope that my presence in my clients lives is a positive, helpful, and even transformational experience. But if the idea of the “corrective emotional experience” is defined only in the disconfirming of patients’ distortions or projections, what options did I have besides self-abandonment, shame, and striving again when these repetitions and ruptures occurred?
A More Freeing View
Nowhere in the text did I find an appreciation for how often the therapist embodies and enacts the harmful dramas of a client’s life—and how corrective it can actually be when this is acknowledged and worked through together.
This expanded view has felt freeing to me. When I hold that both the disconfirming AND the confirming of harmful dynamics in the here and now can be corrective, I become more curious about the various states and “characters” that emerge on the stage.
Without this awareness, I worry how many training models unknowingly double down on the common trauma in a therapist’s life: the pressure to be a “good, helpful, and therapeutic” presence that restricts our ability to be fully ourselves, both inside and outside our work.
A Note for the Discouraged
If this finds you discouraged, confused, or disillusioned by the enactments and ruptures so common in this work of being with other humans, I hope it helps you access a little more curiosity and wonder—and a little less shame and striving.
Keep up the great work.
Alex
And make sure to join my monthly newsletter here if you’d like to continue the conversation.

